What are the benefits of animation versus live action films?

While animation and live action film can both create compelling narratives and strong emotional connections, they offer very different creative possibilities. Live action relies on real people (which can create permission issues), crew, locations, and physical constraints, which can be costly and time-consuming, whereas animation is limited only by the imagination (albeit budgets do play a role).


Pros and cons

Live-action films use physical elements, people, costumes, settings, and lighting to bring stories to life. This often makes characters feel more authentic and relatable. 

However, live-action filmmaking has limitations. It’s restricted by what can be physically filmed, budgets, safety concerns, and real-world constraints. 

Animation, on the other hand, goes beyond these limitations. 

In an animated film, anything can exist: we can make animals, objects can come to life, entire worlds can be invented from nothing, and characters can be based on real-life examples yet remain anonymous. This gives us complete creative freedom, allowing us to explore complex or sensitive topics. Take, for example, these films that combine live action and animation to tell the personal stories of a group of teenage girls in conflict-affected South Sudan, using their own drawings and voices to tell their personal stories anonymously but without losing impact.


Universal storytelling

Animated characters don’t have to belong to a specific race, age, gender or nationality unless the creators choose them to. This can make stories more accessible across cultures and languages. Animation also enables highly stylised storytelling that aligns with brand identities, using colour, shape, and movement to create mood and meaning in ways that live action can’t. 

Location isn’t a problem for animation, as you can see in this animation set in the Upper Guinean Forest created to educate Indigenous people and local communities to make informed decisions about their participation (or not) in the REDD+ programme, which is one of many approaches to the climate crisis.


Animating thoughts and emotions

Animation is also effective for representing aspects that are difficult to film, such as internal thoughts, mental health, or imagined experiences. For example, emotions can be shown as characters, and fears can become monsters, helping audiences – especially children and young people – to understand complex feelings, as demonstrated in this animation we developed to raise awareness of how to spot signs and support children and young people with autism who may be experiencing suicidal thoughts or behaviours.

Finally, animation is a universal language. It crosses cultural, age, and linguistic barriers more easily than live-action. Global audiences can relate to animated characters because they’re not tied to a specific real-world identity. This makes animation especially powerful for universal storytelling.


Summary

Live action

  • Relies on footage you’ve filmed or stock footage.
  • Dependent on weather, lighting and real-world conditions.
  • Requires actors or appropriate permissions from ‘real’ people.
  • Locations and sets must physically exist.
  • Mistakes are costly and time-consuming to correct or re-film.
  • Creativity can be limited by safety, budgets and logistics. 

Animation

  • Any world, scene or character can be created. 
  • Animators can create the weather, lighting and environments.
  • No permissions are required for animated characters; they can be any age, gender or ethnicity.
  • Stories can be told anonymously.
  • Scenes can be added, replicated, and easily modified without re-shooting.
  • Perfect for expressing emotions, thoughts and imagination.